CNBC Investing Club vs Action Alerts PLUS 2024: Which is better?

Jeremy Biberdorf
By: Jeremy Biberdorf


This page may contain affiliate links. This means we earn a small commission (at no additional cost to you) if you purchase a product through our links.

In a world where savvy investors are constantly seeking an edge in the market, subscription-based investment newsletters and clubs have gained significant popularity. Whether you’re a seasoned trader or a rookie dipping your toes into the world of investing, it’s natural to be curious about which platform offers the most valuable insights and guidance. In this article, we’re putting the spotlight on two of the most talked-about investment platforms: CNBC’s Investing Club and Action Alerts PLUS.

For more detailed analysis of each product check out our full reviews:

CNBC Investing Club is better for:Action Alerts PLUS is better for:
Investors seeking Jim Cramer’s expertiseInvestors preferring a diverse approach
Exclusive content from Jim CramerAffordable subscription options
Learning from a personal portfolioAccess to various features and resources
Emphasis on real-time alertsCombination of fundamental & technical analysis

By comparing these two giants across three key factors – the quality of research and advice, user experience, and pricing – we aim to help you make an informed decision about which platform can best support your financial goals.

CNBC Investing Club Action Alerts PLUS
Service Type Investment newsletter and alerts Investment newsletter, alerts, and educational resources
Fees $49.99 per month or $399.99 per year $29.99 per month, $299.99 per year, $499.99 for two years
Customer Service Email support and limited phone support Email support, phone support, and online forum
Best Use Learning from Jim Cramer's expertise Diversified investment approach and education
Modest Money Review CNBC Investing Club Review Action Alerts Plus Review
Current Promotion

More Info

More Info

Modest Money Overall Rating
3.5 rating based on 5 ratings
4.5 rating based on 5 ratings

Factor 1: Investment Philosophy and Features

CNBC Investing Club Offers Real-Time Alerts, Stock Ideas, and Exclusive Content from CNBC’s Jim Cramer

  • Action Alerts PLUS: Offers Real-Time Action Alerts, Daily Rundown Videos, and exclusive access to Member-Only Monthly Calls

CNBC Investing Club website

CNBC Investing Club, led by renowned financial expert and Mad Money host Jim Cramer, aims to provide investors with insights and strategies to navigate the market successfully. The platform revolves around Cramer’s extensive experience and expertise in finance and investing, offering subscribers a chance to learn from one of the industry’s most prominent voices.

Subscribers to the CNBC Investing Club receive real-time alerts on stock ideas and market trends, access to Cramer’s personal portfolio, and exclusive insights and analysis from Cramer and his team.

Additionally, the Investing Club provides detailed research reports on various industries and sectors, empowering users to make informed decisions when choosing stocks for their portfolios.

Action Alerts PLUS

Action Alerts PLUS, originally associated with Jim Cramer and TheStreet, is now operated by The Arena Group under the guidance of co-portfolio managers Chris Versace and Bob Lang. Both are seasoned financial professionals with extensive experience in portfolio management, options trading, index building, and monitoring the global economy and monetary policy. The service focuses on identifying the best investment opportunities in the market by leveraging their collective expertise.

Subscribers of Action Alerts PLUS can expect diverse investment ideas driven by structural changes in the global economy, demographics, psychographics, technology, and regulatory mandates. The platform also aims to educate investors on technical analysis and options trading, offering valuable tools to navigate both short-term and long-term market movements.

Action Alerts PLUS offers numerous features, including Real-Time Action Alerts, 24/7 access to the portfolio, Daily Rundown Videos, exclusive access to Member-Only Monthly Calls, and an Online Forum.

While both CNBC Investing Club and Action Alerts PLUS provide expert advice and stock recommendations, their approaches to investing differ slightly. CNBC Investing Club focuses on Cramer’s personal investment strategies, offering subscribers a more individualized experience as they learn from his market insights and analysis.

In contrast, Action Alerts PLUS takes a more collaborative approach, led by co-portfolio managers Chris Versace and Bob Lang, who bring their distinct expertise and experience to the table.

Moreover, CNBC Investing Club places a strong emphasis on real-time alerts and exclusive content from Jim Cramer, whereas Action Alerts PLUS focuses on a broader range of features such as daily rundown videos, monthly calls, and an online forum. This distinction allows investors to choose the platform that aligns with their preferences and investment style.

Factor 2: Stock Picking Methodology

CNBC Investing Club Focuses on Jim Cramer’s investment strategies and personal portfolio

  • Action Alerts PLUS: Utilizes a combination of fundamental and technical analysis for stock selection

CNBC Investing Club

The CNBC Investing Club’s stock-picking methodology revolves around Jim Cramer’s investment strategies and personal portfolio. Drawing from his decades of experience in the financial industry, Cramer provides subscribers with insights into his decision-making process and stock selection criteria. This approach aims to help investors understand the rationale behind each recommendation, enabling them to apply these learnings to their investment decisions.

Cramer’s investment philosophy is grounded in a thorough analysis of market trends, company fundamentals, and macroeconomic factors.

By sharing his stock picks and strategies, the CNBC Investing Club offers investors an opportunity to learn from Cramer’s wealth of knowledge and expertise, empowering them to make better-informed investment choices.

Action Alerts PLUS

Action Alerts PLUS adopts a comprehensive approach to stock picking by combining both fundamental and technical analysis. Co-portfolio managers Chris Versace and Bob Lang use their vast experience in portfolio management, options trading, and index building to identify promising investment opportunities across various industries and sectors.

Their focus is on uncovering stocks poised to benefit from structural changes in the global economy, demographics, psychographics, technology, and regulatory mandates. By employing a mix of fundamental and technical analysis, Action Alerts PLUS ensures that its subscribers receive well-rounded and timely investment ideas.

The stock-picking methodology of Action Alerts PLUS caters to investors looking for a more diversified approach to investing, encompassing both short-term and long-term market trends. By offering insights into both fundamental and technical analysis, the platform equips subscribers with the knowledge and tools to navigate various market conditions and make informed investment decisions.

Factor 3: Pricing and Subscription Options

CNBC Investing Club: Higher cost – $49.99 per month or $399.99 per year

  • Action Alerts PLUS: Provides monthly, annual, and biennial plans at a lower rate that CNBC offerings

CNBC Investing Club

CNBC Investing Club offers two subscription plans to cater to a variety of investor preferences and budgets. The platform provides a monthly membership option priced at $49.99 and an annual subscription at $399.99. Subscribers can choose a plan that best suits their needs, with each granting access to the platform’s features, such as real-time alerts, stock recommendations, and exclusive content from Jim Cramer.

By offering flexible subscription options, CNBC Investing Club ensures that investors with different levels of experience and financial commitment can benefit from its valuable insights and guidance.

Action Alerts PLUS

Action Alerts PLUS presents subscribers with various subscription options, ensuring a level of flexibility that caters to individual preferences. The pricing plans include $29.99 per month, $299.99 per year, and $499.99 for two years (at $20.83 per month).

Subscribers can expect to receive exclusive market insights, portfolio guidance, stock ratings, technical analysis, weekly roundups, and real-time email alerts. With these resources, subscribers gain transparency into a professionally managed portfolio, strategic buy and sell recommendations, and an easy-to-follow stock rating system.

CNBC Investing Club vs Action Alerts PLUS – Final Thoughts

Both CNBC Investing Club and Action Alerts PLUS offer valuable resources and guidance for investors looking to enhance their market knowledge and investment strategies. While CNBC Investing Club offers the unique opportunity to learn directly from Jim Cramer’s expertise and personal portfolio, Action Alerts PLUS provides a more diverse approach led by co-portfolio managers Chris Versace and Bob Lang.

One of the most significant factors distinguishing these two platforms is their pricing and subscription options. Although CNBC Investing Club offers valuable insights from a renowned financial expert, its higher subscription fees of $49.99 per month or $399.99 per year may be a deterrent for some investors. On the other hand, Action Alerts PLUS offers more affordable pricing plans, starting at $29.99 per month, $299.99 per year, or $499.99 for two years, making it a more budget-friendly option.

Moreover, the diverse investment ideas and stock-picking methodologies employed by Action Alerts PLUS, including fundamental and technical analysis, cater to a wider range of investors with varying investment styles and risk tolerance. With its wide array of features, such as daily rundown videos, monthly calls, and an online forum, Action Alerts PLUS offers a more comprehensive user experience.

While both platforms have their merits, Action Alerts PLUS emerges as the winner due to its more affordable pricing, diverse investment approach, and broader range of features. Investors looking for a comprehensive, budget-friendly platform that offers a mix of investment ideas, stock recommendations, and educational resources would benefit from choosing Action Alerts PLUS.

Click here to get started with Action Alerts PLUS.

Learn More About Action Alerts PLUS