Empower Retirement vs Vanguard 2024

Jeremy Biberdorf
By: Jeremy Biberdorf
Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. This means we earn a small commission (at no additional cost to you) if you purchase a product through our links.

Empower Retirement and Vanguard are two prominent names in the retirement planning and investment industry, each offering unique services to cater to different investor needs.

Our objective is to provide a clear and balanced overview, helping investors make informed decisions about which platform best suits their retirement and investment goals.

Empower Retirement is Better for:Vanguard is Better for:
Ideal for those seeking personalized retirement planning services.Suitable for investors focusing on low-cost index funds and ETFs.
Great for investors interested in a wide range of retirement account options.Excellent for self-directed investors preferring a hands-off investment approach.
Perfect for users wanting robust customer support and advisory services.Ideal for those seeking a platform with a strong track record in mutual funds.
Best for those looking for innovative tools and resources for retirement planning.Great for long-term investors prioritizing low fees and a broad range of funds.

Introducing the Platforms

Empower Retirement

Empower Retirement distinguishes itself in the retirement planning sector with a strong emphasis on tailored solutions. It shines in offering a variety of retirement account options, including personalized 401(k)s and IRAs, tailored to individual retirement goals.

This approach is complemented by comprehensive advisory services, where each client receives specific guidance based on their unique retirement aspirations and financial circumstances. This specialization makes Empower an ideal choice for a diverse range of investors, from those just beginning their retirement journey to seasoned savers approaching retirement.

Empower’s standout feature is its commitment to personalizing the retirement planning experience, making it a strong contender for those seeking a more guided approach. Check out my Empower Retirement review for even more context.


Vanguard stands as a titan in the investment industry, particularly renowned for its pioneering role in low-cost index funds and ETFs. This focus on affordability and simplicity makes it a favorite among self-directed investors who prefer a more hands-off investment strategy.

Vanguard’s reputation is further bolstered by its significant presence in the mutual fund market, offering a plethora of investment options for sustained long-term growth. The platform’s emphasis on low fees and a wide fund range positions it as a top choice for investors seeking cost-effective, long-term investment solutions.

Vanguard’s streamlined, user-friendly approach is particularly appealing to investors who value ease and efficiency in their investment endeavors.

Empower Retirement Logo  Vanguard Logo
Type of Service Personalized retirement planning Low-cost index funds and ETFs
Best Use Diverse retirement account options Long-term, low-cost investing
Customer Support Comprehensive advisory services Basic customer support
User Experience User-friendly with robust support Straightforward with a focus on simplicity
Current Promotion

More Info

More Info

Modest Money Overall Rating
4.2 rating based on 5 ratings
4.0 rating based on 5 ratings

Factor 1: Retirement Planning and Services

Empower Retirement offers comprehensive retirement planning services

  • Vanguard is known for its low-cost investment options.
  • Empower Retirement is preferred for its personalized retirement planning and advisory services.

Empower Retirement excels in providing a comprehensive range of retirement planning services. It stands out for its personalized approach, offering tailored advice and support to help individuals navigate their retirement journey.

With a focus on diverse retirement account options and customer-centric advisory services, Empower Retirement is an ideal platform for those seeking a guided and customized retirement planning experience.

Vanguard, while offering a strong selection of low-cost investment options, primarily focuses on self-directed investing rather than personalized retirement planning. Its strength lies in providing cost-effective investment strategies, particularly through its index funds and ETFs.

However, for investors seeking more personalized retirement planning and advisory services, Empower Retirement offers a more fitting solution.

Factor 2: Investment Options and Flexibility

Empower Retirement provides a wide range of retirement account types and investment options

  • Vanguard excels with its extensive selection of low-cost index funds and ETFs.
  • Empower Retirement wins for its broader diversity in retirement account choices.

Empower Retirement’s platform is tailored to offer a variety of retirement account types, including 401(k)s, IRAs, and other specialized retirement plans. This diversity allows investors to choose the options that best fit their individual needs and financial goals.

Additionally, Empower offers a range of investment choices within these accounts, catering to different risk tolerances and investment strategies.

Vanguard, known for its extensive selection of low-cost index funds and ETFs, provides excellent options for long-term investing. While Vanguard’s offerings are ideal for investors focused on cost-effective fund options, its range of retirement account types is not as broad as Empower’s.

For investors seeking a platform that offers a wider array of retirement account options and investment flexibility, Empower Retirement stands out as the more versatile choice.

Factor 3: Fees and Costs

Vanguard is renowned for its low-cost investment options

  • Empower Retirement offers competitive fees with valuable advisory services.
  • Vanguard is preferred for its focus on minimizing fees for investors.

Vanguard has established a reputation for offering some of the lowest fees in the investment industry, particularly with its index funds and ETFs.

This cost-effective approach is a significant advantage for long-term investors who are mindful of how fees can impact their investment returns over time. Vanguard’s focus on low fees makes it a highly attractive option for cost-conscious investors.

Empower Retirement, while offering competitive fees, tends to have a pricing structure that reflects its comprehensive advisory services and personalized retirement planning.

Although its fees are justified by the range of services provided, investors who prioritize minimal fees would find Vanguard’s low-cost approach more appealing.

Factor 4: Customer Support and Advisory Services

Empower Retirement provides robust customer support and personalized advisory services

  • Vanguard offers basic customer support with a focus on self-service.
  • Empower Retirement is superior for its dedicated customer support and professional financial advice.

Empower Retirement differentiates itself with its strong focus on customer support and advisory services. Investors have access to professional financial advisors who can provide personalized guidance tailored to their specific retirement goals and financial situations.

This level of support is particularly beneficial for investors who value direct advice and assistance in managing their retirement accounts.

Vanguard, while offering reliable customer support, places more emphasis on a self-service model, which aligns with its approach of empowering investors to make their own investment decisions.

However, for those who prefer more hands-on support and professional advice, Empower Retirement offers a more comprehensive service.

Factor 5: User Experience and Platform Accessibility

Empower Retirement offers a user-friendly platform with accessible tools and resources

  • Vanguard provides a straightforward platform, suitable for self-directed investors.
  • Empower Retirement is preferred for its intuitive user experience and comprehensive tools.

Empower Retirement’s platform is designed with the user in mind, offering an intuitive interface that makes navigating retirement planning and investment options straightforward and accessible.

The platform’s tools and resources are tailored to assist investors in understanding their retirement plans and investment choices, enhancing the overall user experience.

Vanguard, known for its straightforward and no-frills platform, appeals to self-directed investors who prefer simplicity and efficiency. While Vanguard’s platform is effective for its intended purpose, it may lack some of the interactive tools and resources that enhance the user experience found on Empower Retirement’s platform.

For investors who value a platform that combines ease of use with a wide range of helpful resources, Empower Retirement offers a more satisfying experience.

Factor 6: Technology and Innovation

Empower Retirement leverages advanced technology to enhance retirement planning.

  • Vanguard focuses on innovating its investment strategies and platform features.
  • Empower Retirement leads in integrating technology for a more dynamic retirement planning experience.

Empower Retirement stands out for its innovative use of technology in retirement planning. The platform incorporates cutting-edge tools and resources to offer a dynamic and interactive experience.

This technology-driven approach not only simplifies the retirement planning process but also provides clients with a more engaging and informative journey. Empower’s commitment to integrating the latest technological advancements ensures clients receive the most current and efficient retirement planning services.

Vanguard, while also embracing innovation, primarily focuses on refining its investment strategies and enhancing platform functionalities. Their commitment to technological advancement is evident in the continual improvement of their investment offerings and user interface, ensuring clients have access to the latest features and a seamless investment experience.

Vanguard’s dedication to innovation makes it a strong choice for investors who value a platform that evolves with the times.

Factor 7: Education and Resources

Empower Retirement offers extensive educational materials on retirement planning.

  • Vanguard provides a wealth of resources on investment strategies and market insights.
  • Empower Retirement excels in offering comprehensive education tailored to retirement.

Empower Retirement goes above and beyond in providing educational resources specifically focused on retirement planning. Their platform features a wide range of materials, from detailed guides to interactive tools, all designed to enhance clients’ understanding of retirement strategies and options. This emphasis on education empowers clients to make informed decisions and better prepare for their retirement years.

Vanguard, on the other hand, offers a rich repository of investment-related educational content, including insights into various investment strategies and market trends. Their resources are valuable for clients looking to deepen their understanding of the broader investment landscape.

Vanguard’s commitment to providing extensive educational materials makes it an ideal platform for investors who wish to broaden their investment knowledge and stay informed about market developments.

The Verdict

In the comparison between Empower Retirement and Vanguard, each platform offers unique strengths that cater to different investor needs.

Vanguard, with its focus on low-cost index funds and ETFs, and a straightforward platform, remains a strong contender, especially for self-directed investors and those looking for a cost-effective, long-term investment strategy.

With that said, Empower Retirement is the winner of this matchup. The platform stands out for its personalized retirement planning services, diverse retirement account options, competitive fees that align with its advisory services, and a user-friendly platform. This makes it an excellent choice for investors who seek a guided, comprehensive approach to retirement planning and investment.

Click here to get started with Empower Retirement today.

Learn More About Empower Retirement

Frequently Asked Questions

How does Empower Retirement personalize retirement planning?

Empower Retirement personalizes retirement planning by offering tailored advice and support, focusing on individual retirement goals and financial situations. This customized approach is reflected in their diverse retirement account options and advisory services.

What makes Vanguard a popular choice for self-directed investors?

Vanguard is popular among self-directed investors due to its low-cost index funds and ETFs, straightforward platform, and reputation for long-term, cost-effective investment strategies.

What technological innovations does Empower Retirement incorporate?

Empower Retirement integrates advanced technology in its platform, offering dynamic tools and resources to simplify and enhance the retirement planning experience for clients.

How does Vanguard innovate its investment platform?

Vanguard focuses on refining investment strategies and platform functionalities, regularly updating features and user interfaces to provide clients with a seamless and current investment experience.

What types of educational resources does Empower Retirement provide?

Empower Retirement offers a wide range of educational materials, including detailed guides and interactive tools, focused on retirement planning and strategies.

What kind of investment education can clients expect from Vanguard?

Vanguard provides an extensive collection of educational content on investment strategies, market trends, and insights, catering to clients looking to expand their investment knowledge.

How do Empower Retirement’s advisory services benefit clients?

Empower Retirement’s advisory services provide personalized guidance and support, ensuring clients’ retirement plans align with their unique financial goals and situations.

What is Vanguard’s approach to customer education and market insights?

Vanguard’s approach to customer education involves offering a wealth of resources and insights into investment strategies and market trends, helping clients make informed investment decisions.