Investment Newsletter Reviews & Ratings

Jeremy BiberdorfBy: Jeremy Biberdorf

September 24, 2023September 24, 2023

With so many investment newsletters out there, how do you know which ones are worth your time and money? The key is finding newsletters that provide timely, actionable advice to help you navigate the ever-changing markets.

Look for newsletters with a proven track record of success and a reputable editor or team behind them. Check sites that provide unbiased reviews and ratings to see each newsletter’s historical performance and get a sense of other investors’ experiences.

These financial newsletters that have been published for many years have demonstrated their ability to provide value through different market cycles. Look for a consistent editorial vision and investment philosophy. The editor or team’s expertise and experience are hugely important.

Best Investing Newsletters

If you’re looking for investment newsletters, here are some of the best options:

  • Motley Fool Stock Advisor
  • Trade Ideas Trade of The Week
  • Seeking Alpha
  • Mindful Trader
  • Oxford Communique
  • Oxford Income
  • Morningstar Premium
  • Behind the Markets
  • TickerNerd

Motley Fool Stock Advisor

 Motley Fool Stock Advisor Logo

The Motley Fool Stock Advisor service provides investors with stock picks and advice to build a solid portfolio. For a monthly fee, you gain access to a wide range of training tools and trading information. For a relatively low cost, the Motley Fool Stock Advisor service gives you the potential to beat the market through its time-tested stock-picking methodology.

Their recommendations are geared toward long-term individual investors looking to build wealth over time through owning stocks in great companies. If you’re willing to buy and hold, this service could be a valuable tool for your investment strategy.

Motley Fool Stock Advisor Ratings and Reviews

  • Trustpilot 3.5
  • Day Trade Review 4.4

Jim Haley – September 11, 2023

“In Shakespeare’s comedy Twelfth Night, there is a fool named Feste who is arguably more intelligent and has a quicker wit than all of the other characters combined. This amazing Fool manages to keep everyone humble alert and prods them with perspective on their decisions and Life. Thank God for our Motley Fool. We certainly need it!!”

Learn More

Trade Ideas Trade of The Week

 Trade Ideas Trade of The Week Logo

Trade Ideas Trade of the Week feature highlights one stock that their AI-based algorithm has identified as a prime opportunity. Every Sunday, Trade Ideas announces a new trade idea to subscribers with details on:

  • The stock symbol and company name
  • A technical and fundamental analysis of why the stock was selected
  • Suggested entry, exit, and stop-loss price points based on the analysis
  • Potential upside and risk level (low, medium, high)

This provides an easy option for subscribers to follow Trade Ideas’ trade alerts and potentially profit from their recommendations.

Trade Ideas Trade of The Week Ratings and Reviews

  • StockScreenerTips 5
  • Capterra 4.7 from 24 reviews
  • Day Trade Review 4.4
  • Liberated Stock Trader 4.5
  • Benzinga 4.5
  • DayTradingz 4.5

Kayla – June 08, 2022

“This is the best trading tool I have ever used. I would not trade without it.”

Learn More

Seeking Alpha

 Seeking Alpha Logo

Seeking Alpha provides stock market analysis and investment tools for both amateur and professional investors. On its platform, you’ll find insights from its staff as well as community members.

They offer a “Quant” rating system to evaluate stocks using factors like value, growth, momentum, income, and safety. Subscribers gain access to their premium services, including stock screeners, portfolio tools, and email alerts. A yearly subscription costs $239.

Seeking Alpha Ratings and Reviews

  • Apple App Store 4.8 from 1102000 reviews
  • GetApp 4.5 from 40 votes
  • WallStreetZen 4.5
  • Capterra 4.5 from 40 reviews
  • Best Wallet Hacks 4.2
  • Trustpilot 4 from 273 reviews

Monte Strong – September 13, 2023

“I like the dividend information presented on the stocks. I do wish there was a way to average what the analysts are saying. Interestingly, two analysts can have reviews in the same three-day period. One buy and one sell. I have never thought that I should pick an author and follow just that person. I do wonder how fast Seeking Alpha is at updating it’s information.”

Learn More

Mindful Trader

 Mindful Trader Logo

Mindful Trader is a breath of fresh air in the investment newsletter industry. Its data-driven approach to swing trading has regularly produced triple-digit returns for subscribers.

Rather than cluttering its website with overhyped marketing claims, Mindful Trader focuses on the numbers. Its simple yet effective alerts help you make better-informed trading decisions. You won’t have to wonder whether the data actually supports its trade recommendations.

Mindful Trader Ratings and Reviews

  • Trustpilot 4.7 from 82 reviews
  • Tradewise Community 4.6
  • Benzinga 4.5

George Curry – July 01, 2023

“The owner/operator of this Site seems to be a transparent person, and I think He is real. I joined the Site specifically to see if I could follow options trading. The training was very good, but I am not capable of doing this program right now effectively. I canceled my subscription services and immediately received a refund. Highly recommend you give it a try for the learning experience.”

Learn More

Oxford Communique

 Oxford Communique Logo

The Oxford Communique is an investment newsletter offered by the Oxford Club, an independent financial publisher. For an annual fee of $49, subscribers receive monthly stock picks, weekly updates, and special reports designed to help you profit in the current market.

Both digital and print subscription options are available. The digital-only choice provides instant access to recommendations and the ability to act quickly on new opportunities. The print subscription includes full digital access as well as a physical copy of the monthly newsletter mailed.

Oxford Communique Ratings and Reviews

  • Stock Gumshoe 4.4 from 2795 votes
  • Best Wallet Hacks 4.2

Robert Schweizer

“By far the best investment newsletter that I have subscribed to (and I have subscribed to a lot of them). You have made a lot of money for me.”

Learn More

Oxford Income Letter

 Oxford Income Letter Logo

The Oxford Income Letter is an affordable investment newsletter focused on high-yield stocks. For $39 a month, it provides stock picks and analysis to generate income and potential strong returns.

The Oxford Income Letter uses four model portfolios of dividend-paying stocks to recommend picks each month. Acting on these selections could allow experienced investors to make money from dividends and share price appreciation.

The newsletter also explains what professional money managers are investing in, news impacting bonds and fixed income, and revisits prior stock picks.

Oxford Income Letter Ratings and Reviews

  • pdFiller 4.5 from 95 votes

Mort Davidson

“Marc, the performance of your dividend picks continues to amaze. I’m making more than $54,000 per year (yield on cash is 6.84%, gain on cash is 14.35%). THANK YOU.”

Learn More

Morningstar Premium

 Morningstar Logo

If you want to take your investment research to the next level, consider a Morningstar Premium subscription. For about $30 a month, Morningstar Premium gives you access to their comprehensive research and tools to help you choose and track investments.

You’ll get in-depth analyst reports on stocks and funds to understand the pros and cons before you invest. You can set up watchlists to monitor the performance of investments you own or are interested in. Morningstar’s portfolio analysis tool will show you exactly how much risk you’re taking on and if you’re properly diversified across sectors and styles.

Morningstar Premium Ratings and Reviews

  • Joy Wallet 4.5
  • Best Wallet Hacks 4.5
  • TrustRadius 4.5
  • Apple App Store 4.1 from 6,519 review

Customer Review

Personally, I find Morningstar to be an amazing service. After a free trial, I was happy to pay the high price for the premium. As a value-focused investor, their detailed analysis and valuation of companies saves me a lot of time and energy.”

Learn More

Behind the Markets

 Behind the Markets Logo

As a subscriber to Behind the Markets, you’ll gain access to Dylan Jovine’s monthly stock picks and analysis, with the potential for impressive returns—if his picks perform well.

Depending on your subscription level, you may also receive bonus reports and trading alerts. These alerts notify you if Jovine’s outlook changes drastically so you can take action quickly and potentially avoid missing out on profits. While returns aren’t guaranteed, Jovine aims to find undervalued stocks with the potential for strong growth.

Behind the Markets Ratings and Reviews

  • Day Trade Review 4.5

Learn More


 TickerNerd Logo

TickerNerd is a premium stock-picking newsletter focused on uncovering undervalued US companies for long-term investors.

Their straightforward model provides both free educational content as well as a paid membership to access their monthly stock reports. Once you join, you’ll get full access to their archive of past reports and recommendations.

TickerNerd Ratings and Reviews

  • Product Hunt5 from 7 reviews

Nicholas Renotte – Data Scientist at IBM

“Been trying to automate my finance stuff for a while, namely around repeatable analysis and then I go and find @TickerNerd ?! Simple, straightforward and easy-to-digest stock analytics straight to your inbox (y’all like data, right?”

Learn More

Overall Thoughts on Best Investing Newsletters

While some newsletters provide genuinely insightful financial advice and open overlooked opportunities, others may be purely speculative or driven by ulterior motives. It’s wise to treat newsletters as supplementary resources rather than the sole basis for investment decisions.

For beginners, newsletters offer an introduction to the complex world of investing, reducing the steep learning curve. For seasoned investors, they can provide fresh perspectives. However, not all newsletters are created equal.

Related Links

Jeremy Biberdorf
Jeremy Biberdorf

About the Author:

Jeremy Biberdorf is the founder of Modest Money. He's a father of 2 beautiful girls, a dog owner, a long-time online entrepreneur and an investing enthusiast.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *