Mint vs PocketSmith 2024: Which budgeting app should you use?

Factor 1: Budgeting Features

Mint

Mint is a comprehensive personal finance management tool that focuses heavily on budgeting. The platform offers an intuitive interface that automatically categorizes transactions based on their descriptions, helping users track their spending and identify areas for improvement.

Mint’s budgeting features include real-time alerts when you’re close to exceeding a budget category, the ability to create custom categories, and access to historical spending data. These features make Mint an excellent choice for those who want a hands-off approach to budgeting and expense tracking.

PocketSmith

PocketSmith, on the other hand, allows users to take a more hands-on approach to categorizing transactions. While the platform offers automatic suggestions for categorization, users ultimately have control over how their transactions are categorized. This level of control can be beneficial for those who prefer to have more input in their financial management process.

PocketSmith’s budgeting features include the ability to create custom categories, track spending over time, and set financial goals. Additionally, PocketSmith offers a unique calendar view that displays upcoming income and expenses, making it easier for users to plan for future financial events.

Factor 2: Financial Forecasting

Mint

While Mint excels in budgeting and expense tracking, its financial forecasting capabilities are limited. The platform does not provide tools to help users project their financial future or model different financial scenarios. This limitation may not be a concern for those who are primarily interested in managing their current finances, but it could be a disadvantage for users who want to plan for future financial goals and events.

PocketSmith

PocketSmith stands out in the realm of financial forecasting. The platform offers powerful tools that enable users to project their cash flow, net worth, and account balances into the future. With PocketSmith’s “what-if” scenarios, users can model various financial outcomes based on different income, expense, and savings assumptions.

This level of financial forecasting can be invaluable for users who want to plan for major life events, such as purchasing a home, saving for retirement, or starting a family. PocketSmith’s robust forecasting tools make it an excellent choice for those who want a more comprehensive approach to personal finance management.

Factor 3: Subscription Cost

Mint

One of Mint’s most significant advantages is its cost: the platform is entirely free to use. Users can access all of Mint’s budgeting and expense tracking features without paying a monthly subscription fee. This affordability makes Mint an attractive option for those looking for a powerful yet budget-friendly personal finance management tool.

PocketSmith

PocketSmith offers a free plan with limited features, such as manual transaction importing and basic budgeting tools. For users who require more advanced features, PocketSmith provides two premium plans: the Premium plan, which costs $9.95 per month (or $7.50 per month when billed annually), and the Super plan, priced at $19.95 per month (or $14.16 per month when billed annually).

Premium and Super plans offer features such as automatic transaction importing, advanced budgeting tools, unlimited budgets, and financial forecasting capabilities. While PocketSmith’s paid plans are more expensive than Mint’s free offering, the additional features and capabilities may be well worth the investment for users seeking a more comprehensive personal finance management solution.

Mint vs PocketSmith: Our Summary

Both Mint and PocketSmith offer valuable personal finance management tools, but which platform is the winner depends on your individual needs and preferences.

Mint is a strong contender for those who want a free, easy-to-use platform focused on budgeting and expense tracking. Its automatic categorization and real-time alerts make it an excellent choice for individuals who want a hands-off approach to managing their finances.

However, if you’re looking for a more comprehensive personal finance management solution with robust financial forecasting capabilities, PocketSmith is the clear winner. While it may come with a monthly subscription fee, the added features and flexibility make it well worth the investment for those who want to plan for their financial future more thoroughly.

Click here to get started with PocketSmith

If you’re primarily focused on budgeting and expense tracking, Mint’s free offering may be the perfect fit. On the other hand, if you value financial forecasting and are willing to invest in a more comprehensive personal finance management solution, PocketSmith may be the better option. Ultimately, the choice between these two platforms comes down to what you value most in a personal finance tool and how much you’re willing to pay for it.

Learn More