Jeremy Biberdorf
By: Jeremy Biberdorf
April 28, 2023

The Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks Review 2024

Jeremy Biberdorf
By: Jeremy Biberdorf
April 28, 2023


Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. This means we earn a small commission (at no additional cost to you) if you purchase a product through our links.
Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. This means we earn a small commission (at no additional cost to you) if you purchase a product through our links.
Everlasting Stocks Logo


4.5 rating based on 5 ratings

Get Started

In a nutshell: Everlasting Stocks is a Motley Fool subscription giving you Tom Gardner’s picks for stocks to “buy today and hold forever.” This is a departure from other Motley Fool subscription services, which feature stocks to hold for around five years.

Read our Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks review to learn how it can help your investing portfolio.

FeesMinimum InvestmentPromotion
$299 per year, $99 discount for first yearN/AClick Here!
Pros & Cons
  • Market-Beating Returns
  • Reasonable Price
  • Great Portfolio Builder
  • Long-Term Accuracy Not Established
  • Clunky Website

Brothers David Gardner and Tom Gardner co-founded The Motley Fool investment research service together, but they are not in lockstep when it comes to their investment style. Both Tom and Dave Gardner historically contributed to The Motley Fool’s flagship subscription Stock Advisor, each choosing one stock a month to feature as a medium-term growth prospect.

You can read more about Stock Advisor in our full review.

Then Dave started Rule Breakers, a similar service featuring two stock picks per month, but the stocks were slightly riskier. Both Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers featured growth stocks that should do well in a diversified portfolio of over 25 stocks and should be held for five years. You can read more about Rule Breakers in our full review of the service.

Then Tom started Everlasting Stocks, a subscription that isn’t focused on buying and holding for five years but stocks that could theoretically be held forever. Dave Gardner has stepped down from stock-picking duties but remains Co-Chairman of The Motley Fool. Tom Gardner continues to pick stocks on behalf of Stock Advisor and Everlasting stocks.

Starting in 2018, Everlasting Stocks has outperformed the S&P 500 by more than four times. It is more of a portfolio builder than a stock picker, but they still guarantee you two stock picks per month, though they might not be “new” because they might already have part of the Everlasting Stocks portfolio. They are, however, based on the most current information and analysis.

Everlasting Stocks can be a fantastic way to build that basic stock portfolio with long-term market-beating returns, especially for beginner or experienced investors who don’t have much time to choose investments.

Get Startedby clicking here,or continue reading for a deeper dive into our review of The Motley Fool’s Everlasting Stocks service.

What is Motley Fool’s Everlasting Stocks?

The Motley Fool bills Everlasting Stocks as stocks you can “buy today and hold forever.” They also claim to choose Everlasting Stocks from the only publicly traded stocks Tom Gardner owns. Millions of The Motley Fool’s capital is also invested in these stocks.

Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks relies on a team of experienced analysts and stock advisors who meticulously research and analyze individual stocks before making investment recommendations. These stock advisors focus on finding high-growth stocks with strong potential for long-term success, which aligns with the service’s goal of providing stocks that can be held “forever.”

Simply put, The Motley Fool has several outstanding investment subscriptions, but Everlasting Stocks are those long-term growth prospects the brains at The Motley Fool believe in above all others.

Foundational Stocks

When you sign up for Everlasting Stocks, you get immediate access to 15 stock picks that you can buy right away to build yourself an excellent basic portfolio. Remember, the intent of Everlasting Stocks is to help you create a portfolio of stocks that you will mostly hold forever, so you won’t have to do a lot of trading.

New Recommendations

You will then get two new buy recommendations each month to add to your Everlasting Stocks portfolio. These picks are intended to help investors build a diversified portfolio of stocks that can withstand market volatility and provide solid returns over the long term.

Whether you follow the guidance is up to you. With all its products, The Motley Fool recommends having a diversified portfolio of at least 25 stocks and being prepared to hold them for at least five years.


Unlike other investment research companies, The Motley Fool enables you to access the perfect amount of research, not too much or too little. As an Everlasting Stocks subscriber, you will have access to all the articles and videos posted by the service, current and historic.

Even if you plan to mostly go along with the picks without having to do a lot of extra reading, these articles are useful to help you understand what you have invested in and why. They are also a great tool for investor education.

Everlasting Stocks also has a “Rankings” section, where you can see how each Everlasting Stocks recommendation stacks up against fellow recommendations. This can help allow you to choose which stocks you should add first, as well as their overall weight in your portfolio.

These Rankings are updated regularly to be sure you are getting the absolute latest information on your prospective stocks.


As a member of Everlasting Stocks, you will also have access to Community Discussion boards that are surprisingly useful. The Motley Fool Premium members are intelligent, and reading and participating in these boards will do wonders for your own investing knowledge.


When you buy a Motley Fool premium product, you can also build a Watchlist of stocks to make sure you regularly receive updates on all the stocks that you follow. You can also opt into text and email alerts for these stocks whenever The Motley Fool has changed or updated its guidance, allowing you to get the best market prices when buying or selling stocks after a significant event.

Premium Live Content

Motley Fool’s Everlasting Stocks subscription also offers access to its “Premium Live Content” page, where you can watch daily investing shows on various topics during the normal trading day. Or you can opt into an audio stream and play it in the background during your workday.

These shows cover all sectors and are not linked to any one subscription service, so they are a great way to round out your investor knowledge. On a typical day, shows available might include a Market News Watch, a show on real estate investing, and a presentation about semiconductor stocks.

Even if you only have a chance to listen to a few minutes of these shows daily, they will enhance your market knowledge immeasurably.

Does Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks Beat the Market?

Yes, Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks beats the markets, but as one of The Motley Fool’s newest services, it doesn’t have a long-term record of consistent year-over-year returns. However, in the first several years since its inception, it has achieved returns of 578%, so it does look promising over the long run, even in times of volatility.

As of this review, the returns of Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers were 476% and 261%, respectively, but Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers have persisted through a couple of decades, so they have a better track record of consistent success. To check out how Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers stack up, read our comparison post here.

Out of the three products, Everlasting Stocks is probably your best bet to build long-term returns with fewer trades in your overall portfolio. With Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers, you might have a better chance to luck into that once-in-a-lifetime meteoric grower.

Pricing and Money-Back Guarantee

The Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks is a premium service that offers significant value to its subscribers. The current list price for a subscription is $299 per year, but new subscribers can take advantage of a promotional price of $99 for their first year. Additionally, the service offers a 30-day money-back guarantee, allowing subscribers to try the service risk-free and decide if it suits their investment needs.

Complementary to Other Motley Fool Services

Investors who are already subscribers to the Motley Fool Stock Advisor or Rule Breakers services may find Everlasting Stocks to be a valuable complementary service. The stock picks provided by Everlasting Stocks tend to focus on more stable, long-term growth prospects, while Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers often feature higher-risk, high-reward opportunities.

By combining these services, investors can create a well-rounded, diversified portfolio that caters to different risk levels and investment horizons.

Pros and Cons of Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks

Here are some pros and cons of the Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks subscription service:


  • Good Supporting Evidence – All of Motley Fool’s investment picks are backed by research, and the company does an excellent job providing the rationale for each recommendation. Everlasting Stocks is no exception.
  • Reasonable Price – $299 per year might seem steep, but with this first year’s $99 price, you can’t go wrong. The Motley Fool doesn’t hassle you when it comes to canceling subscriptions, so if you are interested, you can always see if your first year’s return is enough to justify the price for the second year. The Motley Fool’s 30-day money-back guarantee also backs everlasting Stocks, so you can get a rebate if you cancel within the first month.
  • Great Portfolio Builder – If you want some control in building your stock portfolio with only the best picks across The Motley Fool’s subscription services, Everlasting Stocks can help you make the most of your stock investments without relying on a robo advisor or a managed account.


  • Long-Term Accuracy Not Established – At a glance, it seems like Everlasting Stocks is a clear winner over Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers and most other stock prediction services. However, this can be misleading as Everlasting Stocks has only been around for several years, so these atypical results may not hold up over the long run.
  • Website – The Motley Fool’s website is not the most intuitive, especially moving between its “Free” and “Premium” articles. You want to stick with the Premium stuff, as the free articles can be uneven in quality. Once you figure the clunky website out, it’s not too bad.

Is The Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks For You?

Compared to Stock Advisor, Rule Breakers, and other services from other companies, Everlasting Stocks is a perfect subscription for busy professionals who don’t have time to treat their finances like a part-time job but who still want to access great stock information and the analysis that back them up.

Here are some investors who will benefit most from buying the Everlasting Stocks subscription:

  • Busy people who don’t have hours per week to dedicate to stock investment choices
  • Investors who don’t want to trade or rebalance accounts frequently
  • Investors who want to get to know a few companies well instead of owning dozens or hundreds of securities
  • Investors with money they won’t need for short term expenses
  • Investors who would like educational resources about market and stock investing
  • Investors willing to accept moderate risk in exchange for long-term growth prospects
  • Investors with a horizon of five years or more
  • Investors who are willing to spend at least a few minutes a couple of times per month to learn about Everlasting Stocks newest recommendations

Everlasting Stocks is good as a standalone service or add-on to the Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers services. You should seriously consider Everlasting Stocks if you want to build a long-term, growth-oriented stock portfolio but don’t have time to spend researching individual stocks.

With the Motley Fool’s Everlasting Stocks, you’ll receive immediate access to 15 of Tom Gardner’s best stock picks and two monthly stock picks. You’ll also get access to The Motley Fool’s Ranking and other investor resources.

The Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks Review: Bottom Line

The Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks, stock picking subscription service offers a unique and compelling approach to long-term investing, focusing on stocks with the potential to be held “forever.” By combining the expertise of experienced stock advisors and thorough research, the service provides valuable investment guidance and monthly stock recommendations to help investors build a diversified stock portfolio.

While the service’s long-term accuracy is yet to be fully established, its initial success indicates the quality of the stock advisors and the stock picks provided. The reasonable pricing, especially the promotional price for new subscribers, and the 30-day money-back guarantee make it an attractive option for investors looking to test the service without significant risk.

The service can be used as a standalone subscription or as a complementary addition to other Motley Fool services, such as Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers. For investors seeking guidance on building a long-term, growth-oriented stock portfolio without spending extensive time researching individual stocks, the Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks presents a promising solution.

After a thorough review of The Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks subscription service, we feel it has the potential to be a valuable tool for long-term investors looking to create a stock portfolio with market-beating returns. With the expertise of seasoned stock advisors and a focus on high-quality stock picks, the service offers a solid foundation for achieving long-term investment success.

If you are thinking about getting an Everlasting Stocks subscription, click here for the best first-year price of only $99.

Frequently Asked Questions

Although the Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks is new, it has made quite the progress. Since its launch, it boasts of an average return of 578%. So, the Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks look promising. With the Stock Advisor and Rule Breaker’s success, you can hope Everlasting Stocks will be up to the task.

The Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks cost about $299. It may be costly, but it’s worth the price. New members get the opportunity of paying $99 for the first year.

You get a 30-day money-back guarantee, so you cancel if you don’t like the plan.

The Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks is legitimate. It launched in 2018 and has since grown to be valuable.

It’s one of The Motley Fool’s top services.

The Motley Fool is an investment platform that receives high praise from financial critics worldwide. Dave and Tom Gardner founded The Motley Fool in 1993, so their services have the experience that stands the test of time.

Tom and Dave Gardner are advocates of transparency in recommending stocks.

The Motley Fool Everlasting Stocks is the best fit for busy people who don’t have time for stock investments.

Everlasting stock is great for you if you have some money you won’t be using soon and would like to invest it.

Related Investing Product Reviews:

Motley Fool Comparison Posts