Seeking Alpha Complaints And Negative Ratings: What Some Unhappy Users Are Saying

Jeremy BiberdorfBy: Jeremy Biberdorf

December 2, 2023December 2, 2023

Seeking Alpha Logo

Seeking Alpha has carved out a notable position as one of the leading stock research websites globally, attracting over 20 million visits each month. Launched in 2004, it stands out in the crowd of investment newsletters for its extensive, high-quality investment research. The platform’s reputation as “the world’s largest investing community powered by the wisdom and diversity of crowdsourcing” is a testament to its value in providing insightful and diverse investment perspectives.

This popularity is driven by its commitment to offering exceptional tools and services, which are detailed in my Seeking Alpha review. Seeking Alpha has consistently delivered on its promise to provide top-tier investment research, making it a go-to resource for investors seeking reliable and comprehensive market analysis.

However, it’s important to note that there are seeking alpha complaints and negative ratings, as with any service. These often revolve around user experiences with specific aspects of the platform. Despite these complaints, Seeking Alpha’s standing as one of the best investment newsletters remains, largely thanks to its deep insights, diverse opinions, and reliable research that caters to a broad spectrum of investors.
Learn More About Seeking Alpha

What is Seeking Alpha?

Seeking Alpha is a well-established investment research platform, catering primarily to intermediate and advanced investors who are in search of reliable, unbiased, and data-driven information. With a robust network of over 7,000 contributors, the platform publishes an impressive array of more than 10,000 stock analyses each month. This vast content is generated through crowdsourcing, leveraging the insights and expertise of a diverse group of knowledgeable investors.

To maintain the integrity and reliability of its information, Seeking Alpha employs stringent checks on its authors. This scrutiny ensures that contributors are credible and free from conflicts of interest regarding the stocks they analyze. This focus on quality and impartiality is a cornerstone of the platform, setting it apart in the realm of investment research.

Seeking Alpha offers several types of stock ratings that are highly regarded for their ability to predict future stock performance. These include the Quantitative Analysis Rating, the Seeking Alpha Author Rating, and the Wall Street Rating. While the Wall Street Ratings are accessible to all members, including those with free accounts, the more detailed Quantitative and Author Ratings are exclusive perks for Premium members.

Seeking Alpha Complaints And Negative Ratings

Before I dive too deep into the benefits of Seeking Alpha, I’d like to touch on some of the common complaints and negative ratings. After reading through all of the negative reviews I could find, here are some that I believe deserve further discussion:

Mark Frietch

1 review


Mar 14, 2023

Mediocre services for the price

Not overly impressed with the quality of the authors nor the service itself. Their rating of individual stocks is questionable. Also, your account is set up on automatic renewal with no notification the renewal date is approaching. I mistakenly missed the date by 2 weeks and was told no refund was available, only use of another service. Reputable investment services don’t handle clients that way. Will never use service again

Date of experience: March 14, 2023

You can’t always blindly believe all negative reviews you read, take the above complaint for example. First, he questions the reliability of Seeking Alpha stock ratings, which is not backed up by data. Since 2010, the Seeking Alpha “strong buy” recommendations have returned over a 25% average annualized return, far outpacing the S&P 500. Also, the reviewer complains about not being notified the renewal date of his membership was approaching. In my experience, this seems to be the normal way that subscription services operate.

Valentin Varbanov

1 review


Apr 21, 2023

Everything is amazing for US, but i wanted more for Europe

Everything is amazing for stocks, but there are some missing European-only ETFs or niche stock data. Overall great experience, and if I was US-based this would be perfect and a 10/10, but for Europe – a little bit more is desired.

Date of experience: April 21, 2023

This complaint brings up a good point. Although Seeking Alpha does provide information and commentary about international stocks, there is a lot more articles dedicated to US stocks. If you don’t invest heavily in the US stock market, there might be better niche stock newsletters that better serve you.

If you want to look at more reviews, you can consider checking out the Seeking Alpha Reddit reviews. I read through the Reddit threads related to Seeking Alpha myself, and I wasn’t able to find much information that swayed my understanding of the service.

Seeking Alpha Benefits

  • Investment Research: Offers a vast array of articles categorized as Long Ideas, Editor’s Picks, Stock Ideas by Sector, IPO Analysis, and Quick Picks. Premium members can customize their news dashboards for tailored information.
  • Article Sidebars: Provides an at-a-glance understanding of investment details, author’s stock rating, and stock price charts.
  • Author Ratings: For Premium members, showcasing the long-term track record of contributors and their favorite stocks.
  • Quant Ratings: A proprietary methodology for grading stocks, offering ratings from “Strong Buy” to “Strong Sell”.
  • Factor Scorecards: Evaluates stock fundamentals with ratings from “A+” to “F”.
  • Earnings Call Transcripts & Recordings: Collects quarterly financial updates from companies, providing transcripts, presentations, and recordings.
  • Stock Screener: Includes proprietary ratings systems and author analysis, helping in identifying potential investments.
  • Portfolio Monitoring: Allows members to sync investment portfolios and monitor holdings, with personalized alerts for breaking news and stock updates.
  • News Dashboard: Customizable dashboard for reading market headlines, sector-specific news, and ticker-specific updates.
  • Earnings Calendar: Lists upcoming earnings calls and reports, including EPS revisions.
  • Stock Ideas Feed: Shows trending articles and collects content by investing themes.
  • Podcasts: Hosts various investing podcasts covering daily market news to specific investing strategies.
  • Daily Newsletters: Up to 15 free newsletters covering different investment themes.
  • Marketplace: Offers subscription services from Seeking Alpha contributors, including model portfolios.
  • Top Ideas: High-conviction investment recommendations from top-rated authors, including both buying and selling insights.

Seeking Alpha Pricing

Seeking Alpha offers the following 3 membership tiers:

  • Basic Plan: Free with limited content access, suitable for individual investors needing basic analysis tools.
  • Premium Plan: Priced at $239/year, it provides access to most premium features.
  • Pro Plan: At $2400/year, offers full content access including an exclusive newsletter, unique articles, advanced idea screener, short ideas portal, and additional features.

Make sure to check out my Seeking Alpha premium subscription coupon for limited time savings.

Final Thoughts

Wrapping up our discussion on Seeking Alpha, it’s evident to me that this platform is a valuable resource for investors seeking in-depth analysis and a variety of perspectives. However, it’s important to acknowledge some users’ concerns, as noted in Seeking Alpha complaints and negative ratings.

That said, for investors who prioritize detailed research and expert insights, Seeking Alpha could be a significant asset in their investment toolkit. Interested in exploring what Seeking Alpha has to offer and determining its fit for your investment strategy? Click Here to learn more or get started today.

Get Started With Seeking Alpha

Jeremy Biberdorf
Jeremy Biberdorf

About the Author:

Jeremy Biberdorf is the founder of Modest Money. He's a father of 2 beautiful girls, a dog owner, a long-time online entrepreneur and an investing enthusiast.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *