TradeDay vs TopStep 2024

Jeremy Biberdorf
By: Jeremy Biberdorf
 

Disclosure

This page may contain affiliate links. This means we earn a small commission (at no additional cost to you) if you purchase a product through our links.

In the evolving landscape of proprietary trading firms, TradeDay and TopStep stand out as prominent platforms offering unique opportunities for traders to leverage their skills with funded accounts. Both firms provide a pathway for traders to navigate the complexities of the financial markets without the burden of risking personal capital.

This review jumps into the intricacies of both platforms, comparing their offerings, benefits, and potential drawbacks to determine which might serve traders better in their pursuit of trading excellence.

For more detailed analysis of each product check out our full reviews:

TradeDay is Better for:TopStep is Better for:
Best for traders who appreciate clear and simple trading rules.Excellent for new day traders aiming to learn and succeed.
Ideal for those seeking a wide array of learning resources.Favored by futures traders seeking a realistic trading simulation.
Suitable for traders interested in a variety of trading instruments.Chosen by traders who value extensive educational content and live classes.
Great for users who value multiple trading platform options.Preferred for offering a 14-day trial, allowing for a risk-free start.
Perfect for traders looking for competitive profit-sharing structures.Appreciated by traders who need support for popular trading platforms.

Introducing the Platforms

TradeDay

tradeday.com websites

TradeDay emerges as a prop trading firm that paves the way for futures traders to achieve profitability through a unique Evaluation Challenge. Founded by seasoned traders, TradeDay emphasizes transparency, fairness, and education, offering a comprehensive suite of resources like coaching and webinars.

Its straightforward trading rules and appealing profit-sharing model make it a beacon for traders at various levels. For an in-depth exploration of TradeDay and its offerings, including competitive pricing and educational tools – read my comprehensive review of the platform.

TopStepTrader

topstep.com website

TopStepTrader (TopStep) takes a different approach by simulating real trading environments, providing a valuable learning ground for both novice and experienced traders. With support for numerous trading platforms and a robust educational framework, TopStep stands as a nurturing ground for trading skills development.

The firm’s rigorous funding criteria underscore its commitment to fostering disciplined and successful traders. Discover more about how TopStep can fit into your trading journey by reading my full review.

TradeDay logo TopStep logo
Type of Service Prop Trading Firm Simulated Live Trading
Best Use Futures Trading Learning and Succeeding
Customer Support Comprehensive Extensive Support
Unique Features Clear Trading Rules Educational Tools
Integration Multiple Platforms Popular Trading Platforms Supported
Modest Money Review TradeDay Review TopStep Review
Current Promotion Learn More

Use Coupon ‘modestmoney’ for 40% off!

Learn More

Save 60% via link!

Modest Money Overall Rating
4.5 rating based on 5 ratings
4.6 rating based on 5 ratings

Factor 1: Educational Resources

TopStep provides extensive educational tools and live classes

  • TradeDay offers a wide variety of learning resources.
  • TopStep is preferred for its comprehensive and structured educational offerings.

TradeDay is commendable for its dedication to trader education, providing a plethora of resources, including webinars and coaching. These tools are designed to assist traders in refining their strategies and understanding market dynamics, catering to various experience levels.

TopStep, on the other hand, stands out with its extensive range of educational content, including live classes that cater to diverse trader needs. This emphasis on structured learning makes TopStep an attractive option for traders who prioritize education as a cornerstone of their trading approach.

Factor 2: Trading Platforms and Integration

TopStep is compatible with 14 trading platforms, including NinjaTrader and TradingView

  • TradeDay supports multiple trading platforms, offering flexibility.
  • TopStep is favored for its broad platform support, catering to a wide range of trading preferences.

TradeDay offers traders the flexibility to choose from various trading platforms, ensuring they can trade on interfaces they are familiar with and comfortable using. This adaptability is crucial for a seamless trading experience.

TopStep, with its support for a vast array of trading platforms, ensures that traders have access to the tools and features they need to execute their strategies effectively. This extensive platform support gives TopStep an edge for traders seeking versatility in their trading tools.

Factor 3: Profit Sharing and Withdrawal Policies

TopStep offers a 90% profit split for successful trades, with a clear withdrawal process

  • TradeDay has an attractive profit-sharing structure with competitive withdrawal policies.
  • TopStep is slightly favored due to its higher profit split percentage and transparent withdrawal guidelines.

TradeDay is known for its fair profit-sharing model, allowing traders to retain a significant portion of their earnings. The firm’s withdrawal policies are designed to ensure traders can access their funds promptly, contributing to a positive trading experience.

TopStep, with its 90% profit split, offers traders a slightly more lucrative deal. The firm’s straightforward and transparent withdrawal process further enhances its appeal, providing traders with clarity and confidence in managing their earnings.

Factor 4: Trading Challenges and Funding Criteria

TopStep’s Trading Combine simulates live trading environments, setting stringent but fair criteria for funding

  • TradeDay’s Evaluation Challenge is designed to test traders’ skills in realistic market conditions.
  • TopStep is preferred for its comprehensive Trading Combine program, which thoroughly prepares traders for live market conditions.

TradeDay provides a unique Evaluation Challenge that assesses traders’ abilities to navigate the futures market, offering a clear path to funding for those who demonstrate proficiency. This challenge, while potentially daunting for beginners, serves as an effective filter for identifying capable traders.

TopStep’s Trading Combine is renowned for its rigorous approach to trader evaluation, simulating real trading conditions to test traders’ strategies and discipline. This comprehensive program ensures that only the most skilled and disciplined traders are granted funding, making TopStep a top choice for serious traders.

Factor 5: Support and Community Engagement

TopStep excels in providing trader support and fostering a collaborative community through forums and social media

  • TradeDay boasts high-quality customer support and a vibrant trading community.
  • TopStep is slightly favored for its active engagement with the trading community and superior support services.

TradeDay is praised for its responsive customer service and the sense of community it fosters among its traders. The platform encourages collaboration and learning, enhancing the overall trading experience.

TopStep, however, takes community engagement to the next level with its active forums and social media presence. The firm’s commitment to trader support is evident in its prompt responses and helpful resources, making it an ideal platform for traders seeking a supportive trading environment.

The Verdict

Both TradeDay and TopStep offer compelling features for traders looking to leverage their skills in a funded trading environment. While TradeDay provides a straightforward path to funding with its Evaluation Challenge and a wealth of educational resources, TopStep stands out for its comprehensive Trading Combine program, extensive platform support, and deep commitment to education and community engagement.

For traders prioritizing a structured educational framework and a supportive community, TopStep might be the slightly more favorable option – click here to explore further. You may also want to consider exploring TradeDay if it sounds like a good match for your style.

Regardless of your choice, both platforms present valuable opportunities for growth and profitability in the trading world.

Use Coupon ‘modestmoney’ and Get 40% off ALL accounts above $50k!
Save 60% on TopStepTrader Today!

Get Started With TradeDay and Save 20% on Tradeday!

Get Started With TopStep and Save 60% Today!