TradeStation vs E-Trade 2023

Jeremy Biberdorf
By: Jeremy Biberdorf
Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. This means we earn a small commission (at no additional cost to you) if you purchase a product through our links.

In the ever-expanding realm of online trading platforms, two giants stand out: TradeStation and E*TRADE. Both bring unique offerings to the table, with a plethora of features to help both novice and seasoned traders thrive.

In this comparison, we’ll delve deep into what sets each platform apart. Ready to uncover which platform aligns best with your investment objectives?

TradeStation is Better for:E*TRADE is Better for:
Preferred by active traders for its customizable trading platforms.Great for beginner investor education and resources.
Day traders value its high-powered trading platform and tools.Offers a wide range of mutual funds and futures trading.
Simulated trading options assist in risk-free investment decisions.Solid option for long-term investors with diverse portfolios
Superior technological offerings for sophisticated traders.User-friendly mobile trading apps for on-the-go investors.

Introducing the Platforms


TradeStation is more than just an online broker; it’s a haven for traders looking for a platform packed with powerful tools. From TradeStation 4, their advanced desktop platform, to their comprehensive list of features for both stocks and options trades, the platform is lauded by many as the top-performing broker for active traders.

Offering variable commission rates and paper trading to simulate the stock market environment, it’s designed to serve traders ranging from the passionate novice to the professional.

Read more about TradeStation in our dedicated review of the platform.


E*TRADE, a seasoned player in the online brokerage arena, is revered for its wide range of offerings for traders. With products spanning from regular stock trades to mutual funds, and futures trading to its Power Etrade platform, it caters to a diverse target market.

E*TRADE doesn’t just stop at trading. It seeks to educate its users, providing a treasure trove of resources to aid both retail investors and seasoned pros in making informed investment decisions.

TradeStation Logo E-Trade Logo
Type of Service Online Broker Full-Service Online Brokerage
Best Use Active trading Active traders, Retirement planning
Customer Support 24/7 phone & chat 24/7 Phone, Live Chat, Local Branches
Trading Commissions Varies with volume Commission-free for certain trades
Current Promotion

More Info

More Info

Modest Money Overall Rating
4.5 rating based on 5 ratings
3.5 rating based on 5 ratings

Factor 1: Trading Platform & Tools

TradeStation’s desktop platform excels with customizable options

  • E*TRADE’s Power Etrade stands out for user-friendliness.
  • For sheer versatility and power, TradeStation leads the pack.

TradeStation boasts an immensely powerful platform, the TradeStation 4. Specially catered to day traders and those seeking intricate customization options, it allows users to adapt to market volatility with finesse. The platform’s paper trading (simulated trading) feature also lets traders test the waters without financial risks, making it a stellar choice for those wanting to hone their skills.

ETRADE*, on the other hand, shines with its Power Etrade platform. It offers a clean, intuitive interface perfect for those who prefer a more streamlined approach to trading. Coupled with its tools and charts, Power Etrade aids in the valuation of stocks, making the investment journey smoother for its users.

Factor 2: Commissions and Fees

TradeStation offers a clear, competitive commission structure

  • E*TRADE’s pricing on futures and stocks is more conventional.
  • Given the varied needs of traders, TradeStation’s variable commission rates stand out.

TradeStation understands that every trader is unique. Catering to this niche market, it offers variable commission rates, which can be especially beneficial for high-volume traders. Whether you’re dealing in stocks, options, or futures contracts, TradeStation’s fee structure is transparent and often more favorable, especially for those actively trading.

ETRADE*, with its standard options contract fee and regular stock trades commission, aligns more with traditional online brokers. While their fees on trading options and futures are competitive, active traders might find TradeStation’s commission structures more advantageous.

Factor 3: Educational Resources and Tools

E*TRADE excels in offering beginner investor education

  • TradeStation thrives in advanced tools and sophisticated trading insights.
  • For comprehensive educational resources, E*TRADE slightly edges out.

TradeStation primarily caters to experienced and sophisticated traders, hence its educational materials tend to be more advanced. The platform offers in-depth insights into market trends, technologies, and trading strategies, designed for those who already have a good grasp on trading fundamentals.

ETRADE*, in contrast, has a rich repository of resources for beginners. From detailed articles on investment basics to webinars and video tutorials, ETRADE ensures that newcomers aren’t left in the dark. This focus on beginner investor education makes ETRADE a reliable platform for those taking their first steps in the trading world.

Factor 4: Customer Service and Support

TradeStation offers responsive support with a focus on active traders

  • E*TRADE provides diverse support channels for all types of queries.
  • In terms of specialized support, TradeStation emerges as the favorite.

TradeStation places emphasis on ensuring their traders, especially the active ones, have all the support they need. Whether it’s queries about the TradeStation 4 platform, understanding commissions, or insights into futures contracts, their customer service is equipped to handle specialized concerns swiftly.

ETRADE*, being a veteran in the online brokerage space, has developed a robust customer service network. Whether through phone, chat, or email, E*TRADE is ready to assist. They excel in addressing a wide range of questions, from the basics of stock trading to managing standard accounts.

Factor 5: Mobile Trading Experience

TradeStation’s mobile platform caters to high-powered trading on-the-go

  • E*TRADE’s mobile trading apps focus on accessibility and ease of use.
  • For a comprehensive mobile trading experience, TradeStation takes the lead.

TradeStation understands the importance of trading on-the-go. Their mobile platform mirrors the power and versatility of their desktop counterpart, TradeStation 4. With tools optimized for smaller screens and a user-friendly interface, traders can execute complex strategies, monitor market volatility, and manage their investment portfolios seamlessly.

ETRADE* ensures their users don’t miss out while away from their desktops. Their mobile trading apps, while not as intricate as TradeStation’s, emphasize accessibility. It’s designed for quick trades, portfolio checks, and ensuring users stay updated with market news on the fly.

The Verdict

Both TradeStation and E*TRADE bring exceptional offerings to the table. Whether it’s the intricacies of option contracts, the depths of mutual funds, or the day-to-day of stock trading, both platforms have their unique strengths.

However, for those seeking a platform that thrives in technological offerings, advanced tools, and a keen focus on active traders, TradeStation emerges as the top pick. With its sophisticated trading platforms, variable commission structures, and specialized customer service, it caters exceptionally to those looking to dive deep into the trading world.

Ready to kickstart your trading journey with TradeStation? Click here to dive in today and explore a world of opportunities.

It’s vital to align your choice with your trading journey and investment objectives. Whether you’re an active trader or starting off, always remember to stay informed, stay proactive, and trade wisely.
Learn More About TradeStation